The Premier League season has seen its share of managerial shake-ups, with six permanent appointments made mid-campaign. As the final whistle approaches, it’s time to assess which of these changes proved fruitful and which fell flat.

1) Vitor Pereira for Gary O’Neil (Wolves)

Undoubtedly the most successful managerial change of the season. Pereira’s arrival sparked a remarkable turnaround for Wolves, who were languishing in 19th place and five points from safety under O’Neil. Since Pereira took charge, Wolves have amassed 32 points in 18 games – a point-per-game ratio that would have placed them second in the league over a full season. Their form has been exceptional, with only Liverpool, Newcastle, Arsenal, and Manchester City earning more points during Pereira’s tenure. Wolves are now comfortably clear of relegation, highlighting the profound impact of this appointment.

2) David Moyes for Sean Dyche (Everton)

A change that provided a much-needed positive impact at Goodison Park. Moyes’ return to Everton injected a new lease of life into the club, lifting the sombre mood that had enveloped them under Dyche. In his first month, Moyes secured as many wins as Dyche had managed in the entire season prior to his sacking. While the initial bounce has somewhat dissipated, Moyes successfully steered Everton to safety, allowing fans to bid farewell to Goodison Park with a sense of relief and optimism for the future.

3) Ruben Amorim for Erik Ten Hag (Man United)

While Manchester United currently sit in the top half, this managerial change remains a complex one. Amorim’s Europa League campaign has been a saving grace, but their league form has been inconsistent, bordering on relegation-level at times. Questions linger about whether Amorim’s tactical approach is the right fit for the current squad. The fact that this change didn’t occur in the summer raises further questions about the club’s planning and decision-making.

4) Graham Potter for Julen Lopetegui (West Ham)

It’s still early days for Potter at West Ham, but the initial signs haven’t been overwhelmingly positive. While West Ham haven’t been in immediate danger of relegation, their performances under Potter have been underwhelming. Replacing Lopetegui with Potter seemed a logical step, offering a different approach. However, tangible improvements and a clear vision for next season are yet to fully materialize.

5) Ivan Juric for Russell Martin (Southampton)

A change that ultimately failed to prevent Southampton’s slide into relegation. While the task of saving them appeared insurmountable, Juric’s inability to garner more points than his predecessor, Russell Martin, raises questions. Southampton’s situation suggests that perhaps no managerial change could have altered their fate this season.

6) Ruud van Nistelrooy for Steve Cooper (Leicester)

This mid-season appointment has been a disaster for Leicester. Despite being in 16th position when Cooper was sacked, Van Nistelrooy has overseen a dramatic decline in form. Leicester have managed just one win and five points in their last 20 league games. The decision to appoint Van Nistelrooy, seemingly based on his past success against Leicester as an interim manager for Manchester United, appears short-sighted and illogical. Leicester now face the prospect of Championship football next season with a manager whose suitability for that challenge is highly questionable.